Today is (give or take) the anniversary of the start of the Battle of Siffin, during Islam’s First Fitna, or civil war. Regular readers may have heard of it before. The Caliph, Ali, took an army of 80,000 men (this is likely too high in this context) against the governor of Syria, Muʿawiyah, and his 120,000 man army (likewise) in what is now Raqqa province in Syria. Ali’s accession as Caliph had been marred by the assassination of his predecessor, Uthman, and by Ali’s inability and/or unwillingness to bring Uthman’s killers to justice. The latter point especially became a pretext for resistance among several leading members of the Islamic community who had done quite well for themselves under Uthman. They were now worried because it looked like Ali was planning to upend the social order in at least three ways:
- by replacing regional governors
- by instituting a more equitable distribution of tax revenues and booty that would put all Muslims, Arab and otherwise, on an equal footing
- by moving his capital from Medina to Kufa (and thus taking sides in the growing Syria-Iraq rivalry)
There was also a concern that Ali’s accession would turn the caliphate into an inherited monarchical office, since Ali was Muhammad’s cousin and son in-law. But that concern had been a lot more salient in the succession debates right after Muhammad died–by this point Ali was the fourth caliph and fears of a dynasty were less palpable. And anyway, Muʿawiyah actually did turn the caliphate into an inherited monarchical office, so…oops.
Muʿawiyah refused to acknowledge Ali’s right to replace him as governor of Syria, which meant he was also refusing to acknowledge Ali as rightful Caliph, and Ali determined to make him yield. The two armies met at Siffin and camped opposite each other for what we’re told was 100 days, because neither side wanted to fire the first shot, as it were. Then a faction of Ali’s army, known as the Qurra, who had been implicated in Uthman’s murder and were impatient for a fight, took it upon themselves to attack Muʿawiyah’s lines and start the fighting. Despite being (allegedly) outnumbered, Ali’s forces won the battle, dealing Muʿawiyah’s army 45,000 casualties to their own 25,000 (allegedly, again, and I’ll stop beating this dead horse). Tactically the victory was Ali’s, but politically the situation was still in dispute.
Ali was appalled by the loss of life and offered to settle the matter with Muʿawiyah in single combat. But Ali was known as a great fighter, so Muʿawiyah wanted no parts of that deal. Instead, his army took the field again on the third day of the battle (July 28 or thereabouts), but this time carrying copies of the Qurʾan, or pages of it anyway. The reminder that they were killing their fellow Muslims sapped the will to fight right out of Ali’s men, and so it was decided that Ali and Muʿawiyah would each nominate one arbitrator who would rule jointly on their dispute. Thus, despite the lopsided outcome on the field, Siffin is considered inconclusive, as the battle itself did nothing to resolve the underlying cause of the conflict.
Let’s sum up what happened next, which you can read about in detail in my Islamic history series. The arbitration went extraordinarily badly for Ali, with Ali’s arbitrator ruling that Ali should give up the caliphate in lieu of an election and Muʿawiyah’s arbitrator declaring that Muʿawiyah should be caliph. Ali wound up ignoring the arbitrators’ decision and then went to war with the Qurra, who were angry that he’d agreed to the arbitration in the first place. The Qurra split from Ali’s army, and became known as the Khawarij (Kharijites to us non-Arabs), which more or less means “the leavers,” because they left Ali’s army. They eventually assassinated Ali, as they had Uthman, and Muʿawiyah, who was basically the last man standing, became caliph. As a member of the Umayya tribe and the first caliph to pass the throne on to his son, he’s typically credited as the founder of the Umayyad dynasty.
Hi, how’s it going? Thanks for reading; attwiw wouldn’t exist without you! If you’ve enjoyed this or any other posts here, please share widely and help build our audience. You can follow this site (and like, share, etc. its content) on lots of social media outlets. I’m now accepting guest submissions, just email me. Most critically, if you’re a regular reader I hope you’ll read this and consider helping this place to stay alive.